I exclusively fished Callisto Islands trying to get kraken to plushify. I pulled out almost 50 creatures, as well as reviewed the 9 floating down it when I was done.
Here's what came out:
Trench leviathan (5)
Caeralis (6)
T Triak (3)
Kelp Hippocampus (3)
Trench Hippocampus (2)
Copper Pearl Wyrms (2)
Black Pearl Wyrm (2)
Grey Pearl Wyrm (1)
C Dragon Turtle (2)
P Dragon Turtle (1)
Water Hydra (2)
Wind Hydra (3)
Engull (3)
Swallowtail Deshkivari (8)
Rufous Zeratus (2)
All of that before I got one kraken from Callisto Islands. At one point FIVE of the nine creatures were Swallowtails. A creature could be pulled just to be replaced by that very same creature.
I get that there's a lot of MS creatures. Even if you subtract the DPs, the breed-onlys, and the shop-onlys, there's hundreds and I'm sure that it's programmed so that newer have a higher spawn rate. But when you're searching for "very common" and "rare" shows up more often than that, well, while the tributaries are a help, this still adds to the frustration of trying to get goals, or gifts, or shop stock. Trenchies are almost as old as Krakens after all.
Is there perhaps a trick I'm unaware of that helps with finding more specific creatures? Or perhaps something that can be done behind the scenes? I know with the economy and the move and all, it's probably stacking up, but any help would be appreciated. I don't want to keep crashing my computer with a massive frozen-egg tab I'm trying to offload that I can only do one at a time.
Feel free to look at my Holiday Extras and Others tabs to pick out gifts if you want them! 
Want lowest-gen pygmy gemdragons and pgymy crystalwings, psittrax dragons, alt colors