Which path gets you rose imps?

[audrei9]

From my pairs. I was able to collect them when it was much easier to buy creatures way back when.

It's ok, there's a few giveaways that give out those colours of imp. I'll be fine, thank you for offering to buy them for me!

No, no, I'm not buying them. I have already bought them from years ago. Feel free to buy someone else's, but what I was saying is I already own the rose imps and can breed you the colors you don't get from the quest.

Ohhh ok! That's a very generous offer, thank you! I would still like to pay you for them, though.

[Airasyraye]

It's ok, there's a few giveaways that give out those colours of imp. I'll be fine, thank you for offering to buy them for me!

No, no, I'm not buying them. I have already bought them from years ago. Feel free to buy someone else's, but what I was saying is I already own the rose imps and can breed you the colors you don't get from the quest.

Ohhh ok! That's a very generous offer, thank you! I would still like to pay you for them, though.

We can work it out. I've got red and yellow. The yellow I should be able to turn black, but only when it grows up. I'll work on white.

[audrei9]

No, no, I'm not buying them. I have already bought them from years ago. Feel free to buy someone else's, but what I was saying is I already own the rose imps and can breed you the colors you don't get from the quest.

Ohhh ok! That's a very generous offer, thank you! I would still like to pay you for them, though.

We can work it out. I've got red and yellow. The yellow I should be able to turn black, but only when it grows up. I'll work on white.

How do you get the item that turns them black?

[CinnaminDraconna]

https://magistream.fandom.com/wiki/Mysterious_Tin_Box

Not sure if that item will ever come back.. but it came out of a mystery box from the Black Market.

[Airasyraye]

Ohhh ok! That's a very generous offer, thank you! I would still like to pay you for them, though.

We can work it out. I've got red and yellow. The yellow I should be able to turn black, but only when it grows up. I'll work on white.

How do you get the item that turns them black?

The dark fudge with a candied rose from the tin that CinnaminDraconna mentioned down below. I would think it would come back for new players, but IDK. I don't pay attention to the Black Market often. I have a few of them, but I'm out of the saltwater taffy and gryphon carvings.

@Rosehill Would you be the one who could answer if those items would come back for new players?

[Rosehill]

The "Dark Fudge with a Candied Black Rose" item was originally gotten during the 2014 Valentines event, and has on occasion made a return during other events. Most likely they will return again at some point, but at the moment nothing specific has been planned in that regard.

[Airasyraye]

Ohhh ok! That's a very generous offer, thank you! I would still like to pay you for them, though.

We can work it out. I've got red and yellow. The yellow I should be able to turn black, but only when it grows up. I'll work on white.

How do you get the item that turns them black?

I've got red, black, and yellow. I've been trying to trade for white, but so far no luck. You can accept what I have and try to trade the yellow for a white if you like. I'll start the trade. I don't need any gold.

[audrei9]

We can work it out. I've got red and yellow. The yellow I should be able to turn black, but only when it grows up. I'll work on white.

How do you get the item that turns them black?

I've got red, black, and yellow. I've been trying to trade for white, but so far no luck. You can accept what I have and try to trade the yellow for a white if you like. I'll start the trade. I don't need any gold.

Thank you! Once I've bred a bunch, I'll send them back to you!

[Airasyraye]

How do you get the item that turns them black?

I've got red, black, and yellow. I've been trying to trade for white, but so far no luck. You can accept what I have and try to trade the yellow for a white if you like. I'll start the trade. I don't need any gold.

Thank you! Once I've bred a bunch, I'll send them back to you!

They're yours to keep. I don't need anything. I was here when they were easier to get. It's no problem to me to breed some for others. Besides, I like giving things away. Trust me, I use giveaways and events as well, so I get stuff for free from others myself.

[audrei9]

I've got red, black, and yellow. I've been trying to trade for white, but so far no luck. You can accept what I have and try to trade the yellow for a white if you like. I'll start the trade. I don't need any gold.

Thank you! Once I've bred a bunch, I'll send them back to you!

They're yours to keep. I don't need anything. I was here when they were easier to get. It's no problem to me to breed some for others. Besides, I like giving things away. Trust me, I use giveaways and events as well, so I get stuff for free from others myself.

Thank you and thank you again